In de zondagse estafette-rubriek ‘Bericht uit…’ belichten columnisten uit de Caribische delen van het Koninkrijk bij toerbeurt de kanten van hun eiland waarvan zij vinden dat die de aandacht van alle koninkrijksburgers verdienen. Vandaag komt het bericht uit Sint Eustatius.
The Remarkable Story of Statia’s ‘Madame Theatre’
By Alfred Harley
On Fort Oranjestraat 11, in St. Eustatius Statia, stands a building layered with more than 250 years of history known as the Madame Theatre. Its rich history shows that long before film reels flickered inside its walls, the property belonged to the island’s Governor.
In 1776, Johannes de Graaff, the governor of St. Eustatius during the era of the First Salute to the American Flag, lived on this very site. His second wife, whose name history remembers simply as ‘Madame’, became such a presence in local life that the property itself took her title. The compound was enclosed by walls nearly fifteen feet high, so tall that passersby could not see the house inside. Even today, the lower half of that wall still stands, a quiet reminder of a time when privacy and protection defined the estate. After Governor de Graaff’s death around 1800, Madame continued living there, sheltered behind those imposing walls. With no direct heirs, the property eventually passed to the island govern’ place. But it would not be the last time the property reinvented itself.
In the mid-20th century, as many young Statians travelled to the United States to study, one man returned home with big ideas. Charles Arnold, remembered by many simply as Charlie, had experienced American modernity firsthand and built the Madame Theatre in the 1960s, transforming the historic compound into a cinema styled after the Motown-era architecture he admired abroad.
Charlie became was one of the island’s first millionaires and was a true entrepreneur. He secured contracts with MGM Studios, bringing modern films to Statia at a time when such access was rare for small Caribbean communities. Charlie also operated Charlie’s Ice Cream, and the venue also grew into a social hub. Basketball games were played there and it was at one stage a popular Nightclub.
Generations recall it as the beating heart of Oranjestraat where you went not just to watch something, but to be seen. After Charlie’s passing, his expressed desire for the building to remain part of the community was fulfilled. Then came the hurricanes. The roof was torn away, structural weaknesses multiplied, and eventually the building was forced to close. What had once been vibrant went dark.
Now, that story is changing again. The Madame Theatre is one of the cornerstone projects under the Regional Deal Statia 2026, a €10 million economic and cultural revitalization initiative funded by the Dutch government for six major regional projects and twelve complementary initiatives. Eric Hartstra, who has supported the Regional Deal from the Dutch government side since its early proposal stages, describes the initiative as an economic impulse for the island. But in the case of the Madam Theatre, the impact goes beyond economics. Statia born, Raimie Richardson, is Program Manager for the Regional Deal Projects Statia 2026. He says the restoration of Madame Theatre is about more than preserving a building. “It’s about liability in the city centre”, Richardson explains, “Right now, much of the area is offices. There isn’t much happening in the evenings or weekends. The theatre helps change that.”
The renovation budget stands at approximately €1.8 million. The front facade is now a protected monument and will be preserved exactly as residents remember it. Behind it, however, much of the damaged structure has been removed down to a meter below foundation level. Engineers are constructing a new shell designed to meet modern safety standards, including hurricane resilience.
The main building will feature a fully multifunctional interior and the theatre will seat 102 people in a tribunal-style configuration. The seating will be removable to allow the space to convert from cinema to conference hall, performance venue, banquet space, or community gathering area.
Acoustic panels, advanced lighting systems, modern sound equipment, and concealed solar panels are also part of the design. Bathrooms and changing rooms will be included. Behind the theatre, new office spaces are being constructed. All modern additions are being carefully blended into the historic core so the building aligns visually with nearby Government House and the museum at Fort Oranje. During the planning residents were invited to provide input not only on the building’s design, but even on its exterior colours, since no historically fixed colour scheme exists. When completed, the theatre will fall under a foundation responsible for day-to-day programming and governance.
The building itself will remain government-owned, but structured management will ensure consistent events throughout the year. Richardson says the goal is to have the shell and roof completed in time for Statia Day events, with full interior completion to follow. There is even hope that traditional community gatherings such as the annual breakfast typically held at the Lion’s Den, may one day take place inside the restored theatre. And there is one more detail close to the project team’s heart. When the theatre reopens, they plan to honour Charlie Arnold. His original business license, signed by Mr. Vincent Assel Lopes, along with photographs and memorabilia, will be displayed, returning a piece of Charlie to the walls he built.
From a Governor’s walled estate to a 1960s cinema, from nightclub to hurricane-damaged shell, and now to a modern cultural hub, the Madame Theatre has lived many lives. Soon, its lights will shine again, not just as a building restored, but as history remembered and community renewed.